dawahguide newsamall

Objection to Islam is often raised against the death penalty prescribed for apostasy (abandonment of religion). Since religion in Western civilization came to be looked at as a personal choice which cannot be enforced by either Church or state, to execute a person for leaving his religion would naturally seem extreme.

It should be kept in mind that when capital punishment for murder was abolished in the UK in 1965 it was retained for treason and piracy with violence.

And it was also the legal punishment for setting fire to Her Majesty’s ships and dockyards until 1971.  The 1971 Criminal Damage Act replaced capital punishment with life imprisonment for these offences.

It should be kept in mind that when capital punishment for murder was abolished in the UK in 1965 it was retained for treason and piracy with violence. Most countries have executed its citizens for treason. Treason is an act of rebellion against the state. State secrets are given to other countries which may not be at war with the state.

Terrorism is defined by the American government as the threat or the use of violence to advance a political cause by individuals or groups, whether acting for or in opposition to established governmental authority, when such actions are intended to shock, stun, or intimidate a target group wider than the immediate victims.

Actually such a general definition will include all wars of liberation from the American War of Independence to the French Revolution. The worst aspect and perhaps the most common feature of terrorism is the unleashing of violence against innocent civilians.

The State of Israel is the most recent example of the establishment of a state by terrorism. It was established by Jewish terrorist groups, the most infamous of which was the Stern Gang.

The term “Muslim terrorist” is used to label Islam as a terrorist religion. However, it is a misnomer.

When IRA bombers struck, they were not labeled as “Catholic terrorists” even though the struggle is between Catholic Ireland and Protestant Northern Ireland supported by Protestant England.

Likewise, when Timothy McVeigh blew up the Alfred P. Murrah Federal Building, in Oklahoma City on April 19, 1995 killing 168 people, he was not labeled as a “Christian terrorist”, though he was Christian and a terrorist.

Muslim application of criminal law has often been described as Medieval Draconian laws. The application of capital punishment has been banned by the UN and the ECC.

Punishment in Western penology served three functions:

  1. Retribution (justification looking to the past – i.e. punishment, revenge)
  2. Deterrence (justification looking to the future – i.e. prevention)
  3. Reformation

In The Report of the Departmental Committee on Corporal Punishment in England, 1938, the committee’s unanimous opinion was that “corporal punishment was of no value as a deterrent and should be abolished.”

In 1952, in the USA, Justice Hugo Black wrote:

“Retribution is no longer the dominant objective of criminal law. Reformation and rehabilitation of offenders have become important goals of criminal jurisprudence.”

In 1972, Justice Thurgood Marshall wrote:

“Punishment for the sake of retribution is not permissible under the Eighth Amendment.”

In the same year, California’s capital-punishment law was declared unconstitutional. [1] Punishment in Islamic Law, Muhammad Saeed El Awa, p. 87.

For some criminologists “reformation” has become synonymous with “cure”. The criminal is no longer a “bad man” but a “sick man.” [2] Crime and the Penal System, Howard Jones, 3 A convict needs treatment. He is genuinely ill, perhaps physically, almost certainly mentally, and psychiatrically.

The Abolition of the Death Penalty Act of 1965 cancelled capital punishment for murder. The Home Secretary announced on 22nd April 1970 that 172 convicted murderers had been released from prison since 1960, most of them having only served nine years or less of their statutory life sentence. Only five served 12 or more years, nine served 6 or less and one completed only 6 months. [3] Ibid., p. 88

These are not cases of mistaken ruling which was corrected. These were convicted murderers being let out on the public due to their good behavior in prison. Many of them killed again, only to be sentenced for a few more years.

Western penologists have admitted that the penal system has failed utterly in reforming and rehabilitating criminals. Petty criminals enter the system and exit as well trained hardened criminals. Society ends up paying for the crimes committed against it by being obliged to provide food, clothing and shelter for criminals.

In the Islamic system, punishments are placed in three categories: